The Big “But” Fallacy

The big but fallacy involves starting with a generally accepted statement only to negate it at the end with a but. An example is: “Yes, it is wrong to hurt animals, but this time it was different (as I was hungry!)”.

The fallacy is closely related to what is known as the “special pleading”. Here, the ‘but’ gives the ‘special’ exception from the generally accepted rules or ethics.